OK, I think I wasn't clear enough....
We had a website before, hosted at 204.11.244.154, and THAT was supposed to remain as our website.
The change I made per the instructions here (Thank you for responding!) made my sharepoint website "the website" that the public sees.
I need my good old www.calvarybrenham.org website that WAS hosted at 204.11.244.154 to be the one the public sees.
Sorry I wasn't more clear.
Pastor Billy